The Formulaic and Underwhelming Experience of Netflix's I Will Find You

Last year, Netflix faced criticism for allegedly instructing writers to downplay complex storytelling and focus on surface-level thrills, making room for viewers to multitask with their phones or laptops during episodes. This trend continues with I Will Find You, the 13th adaptation of a Harlan Coben novel, which seems designed for background viewing rather than immersive engagement.

Creator Robert Hull brings an ensemble cast, including Sam Worthington, Britt Lower, Milo Ventimiglia, and Madeleine Stowe, together to tell the story of a grieving father, David Burroughs (Worthington), and his sister-in-law, Rachel Mills (Lower), who join forces to find his presumed-dead son. Unfortunately, the show's predictable narrative and underdeveloped characters are let down by the cast's phoned-in performances. The dialogue, often reduced to exposition, fails to create any real tension or urgency.

The show's meandering plot takes us through a series of contrived events, including David's wrongful imprisonment and subsequent escape, all facilitated by convenient connections and plot devices. Even the involvement of wealthy socialite Hayden Payne (Ventimiglia) feels like a shallow attempt to add depth, with his character serving as little more than a plot catalyst. Rachel's connections as a former Boston Globe journalist are similarly glossed over, with her ability to gather information and resources feeling unrealistic and unearned.

I Will Find You also attempts to explore the emotional toll of parenthood, a theme that is underdeveloped and inconsistent. Although the father-daughter FBI task force duo, consisting of Sarah Greer (Browning) and Max Williams (McBride), provides some emotional resonance, their storyline is ultimately overlooked in favor of the more sensational aspects of the plot. As the show's twists become increasingly ridiculous, it's hard not to feel a sense of disappointment and disconnection from the characters.

In a weird way, I Will Find You does hint at some semblance of emotional truth, particularly in its focus on the lengths parents will go to for their children. However, this is largely overshadowed by the show's focus on plot contrivance and its numerous, often cringeworthy, twists. With its lackluster performances, shallow characters, and overreliance on formulaic storytelling, I Will Find You feels like a show that's been made for viewers who can easily multitask and aren't invested in its narrative.

Despite its cast and its ambitious premise, I Will Find You falls short of expectations. This latest Netflix series serves as a prime example of the platform's questionable approach to storytelling, prioritizing second-screen viewing experiences over engaging narratives that might actually capture viewers' attention. If you're looking for a show to watch while you browse your phone or scroll through social media, I Will Find You might just fit the bill. Otherwise, you're better off looking elsewhere.

Category: trending, entertainment, Netflix, second-screen viewing, drama, TV series, I Will Find You, TV critique, Saloni Gajjar, A.V. Club, past media group, I Will Find You Netflix, Sam Worthington, Britt Lower, Milo Ventimiglia, Madeleine Stowe